If you are feeling a little gun-shy about equities these days given the strong performance over the past two years, we recommend you sell or short NYSE Euronext (NYX), one of our Most Dangerous Stocks. Stock exchanges have been very profitable enterprises for most of their history. As more and more trading is electronic and is directed by computers, the exchanges struggle to maintain profit margins. There is little value to add as an exchange in today’s environment. Today’s announcement that NYX’s fourth-quarter net profit dropped 21% from a year earlier to $120 million, or 46 cents a share is no big surprise. And is likely the beginning of a trend where NYX struggles to regain the profits it enjoyed in years past. This company’s best days are behind it. Some of the worst days for the stock are yet to come.
Like all of our Most Dangerous Stocks, NYX has (1) misleading earnings = accounting profits are positive and rising while true, economic profits are negative and falling and (2) high valuation = very high expectations embedded in the current valuation.
Specifically on “misleading earnings”: NYX reported a $957mm increase in GAAP earnings while our model shows economic earnings declined by $641mm (a difference of $1,599mm or 34% of 2009 revenues during the last fiscal year. The majority of this disconnect comes from asset-write offs of $1,249mm, which equals 12% of reported net assets. Given that management is supposed to create value, not destroy it, writing-down $0.12 for every $1 on the company’s balance sheet does not bode well for their ability to create shareholder value. Our recent article on Management Failures explains why investors need to beware large asset-write-downs like those incurred by NYX.
Specifically on the stock’s high valuation: our discounted cash flow analysis of the current stock price of around $33, which shows NYX must grow its net operating profit after tax (NOPAT) at over 11% compounded annually for at least 30 years. A 30-year growth appreciation period with an 11%+ compounding growth rate sets expectations for future cash flow performance quite high. Historical growth rates are much lower. In addition, the stock’s upward movement is handicapped by the current, outstanding stock option liability of $8mm, about 1% of its market value. If the stock price climbs, that option liability grows larger as all of the outstanding stock options move more in-the-money and become more valuable.
Our report on NYX, available here, has detailed appendices for you to see how we perform all calculations.
Overall, the risk/reward of investing in NYX’s stock looks “very dangerous” to me. There is lots of downside risk given the misleading earnings while there is little upside reward given the already-rich expectations embedded in the stock price.
In a business where investors make money by buying stocks with low expectations relative to their future potential, NYX fits the profile of a great stock to short or sell.
Note: Stock pick of the week is updated every Tuesday.