We published an update on this Danger Zone pick on September 19, 2022. A copy of the associated report is here.
Affirm (AFRM: $58/share) was trading at about the same level as it is now when we warned investors against owning the stock on January 31, 2022.
Since then, the company’s latest earnings report disappointment confirms our thesis that the stock is overvalued by 80%+.
We are not surprised to see the company guide expectations lower for revenue and profits because the business is losing market share, lacks competitive advantages, is unprofitable, and faces intense competition.
The recent struggles at Peloton (PTON), historically one of Affirm’s largest merchant partners, only bring more pressure to an already struggling business.
We first alerted investors to the risk in Affirm Holdings when we put the stock in the Danger Zone in October 2021. Since then, the stock has outperformed the S&P 500 as a short by 50%.
We think the stock has much farther to fall as we detail below by using our reverse DCF analysis to quantify how the high the future cash flow expectations baked into the stock’s valuation are.
Current Valuation Implies Affirm Will Be Biggest BNPL Firm in the World
Despite facing larger, more profitable competition, Affirm is priced as if it will be the largest buy now pay later (BNPL) provider, measured by gross merchandise volume (GMV), in the world, on top of immediately achieving profitability.
To justify its current price of ~$60/share, Affirm must:
- immediately improve its NOPAT margin to 8% (above Block’s [formerly Square Inc.] 1% and Affirm’s -41% TTM NOPAT margin), and
- grow revenue by 38% compounded annually (nearly 2x expected industry CAGR through 2028) for the next eight years.
In this scenario, Affirm’s revenue grows to $11.4 billion in fiscal 2029, or 13 times higher than the company’s fiscal 2021 revenue.
If we assume Affirm maintains a revenue per GMV rate of just over 10% (equal to fiscal 2021), then this scenario implies Affirm’s GMV in fiscal 2029 is $109 billion, which is 1.6x Klarna’s TTM GMV at the midway point of 2021. For context, Statista estimates Walmart’s 2020 ecommerce GMV was $92 billion. Affirm must process more than double Walmart’s 2020 ecommerce GMV simply to justify its current valuation. We are skeptical of any BNPL firm ever achieving such high merchandise volume.
56% Downside If Consensus Growth is Realized
We review additional DCF scenarios below to highlight the downside risk should Affirm’s revenue grow at consensus rates, or if margins do not improve as much as the scenario outlined above.
If we assume Affirm:
- immediately improves its NOPAT margin to 8%,
- grows revenue by 46% in fiscal 2022 and 43% in fiscal 2023 (equal to consensus), and
- grows revenue by 22% each year thereafter through fiscal 2029 (equal to projected industry growth), then,
Affirm is worth just $26/share today – a 56% downside to the current price
83% Downside If Margins Remain Capped by Competition
If we assume Affirm:
- immediately improves its NOPAT margin to 4%, which equals Block’s highest ever margin,
- grows revenue by 46% in fiscal 2022 and 43% in fiscal 2023, and
- grows revenue by 22% each year through fiscal 2029 then,
Affirm is worth just $10/share today – an 83% downside to the current price.
Figure 1 compares Affirm’s implied future NOPAT in these three scenarios to its historical NOPAT. For reference, we include Block (SQ) and Shopify’s NOPAT.
Sources: New Constructs, LLC and company filings.
Each of the above scenarios assumes Affirm grows revenue, NOPAT, and FCF without increasing working capital or fixed assets. This assumption is highly unlikely but allows us to create best-case scenarios that demonstrate the expectations embedded in the current valuation. For reference, Affirm’s invested capital has grown 4x from fiscal 2019 to fiscal 2021. If we assume Affirm’s invested capital increases at a similar rate in DCF scenarios two and three above, the downside risk is even larger.
2022 has quickly shown investors that fundamentals matter and stocks don’t only go up. With a better grasp on fundamentals, investors have a better sense of when to buy and sell – and – know how much risk they take when they own a stock at certain levels. Without reliable fundamental research, investors have no way of gauging whether a stock is expensive or cheap.
As shown above, disciplined, reliable fundamental research shows that even after plummeting, Affirm still holds significant downside.
This article originally published on February 11, 2022.
Disclosure: David Trainer, Kyle Guske II, and Matt Shuler receive no compensation to write about any specific stock, style, or theme.